Dk. Kinney et al., THOUGHT-DISORDER IN SCHIZOPHRENIC AND CONTROL ADOPTEES AND THEIR RELATIVES, Archives of general psychiatry, 54(5), 1997, pp. 475-479
Background: Previous research showed significantly elevated levels of
thought disorder in the relatives of persons with schizophrenia, as we
ll as in the persons with schizophrenia themselves. Comparisons of sch
izophrenic and control adoptees and their respective relatives provide
a method for minimizing the confounding of genetic and environmental
sources of familial resemblance and for elucidating whether the elevat
ed levels of thought disorder in persons with schizophrenia and their
relatives reflect the influence of shared genetic factors, shared envi
ronmental factors, or both. The present study provides the first such
adoption-sample data on an operationally defined measure of thought di
sorder. Methods: Speech samples elicited by standard interview questio
ns from schizophrenic and control adoptees and their respective biolog
ical and adoptive relatives were tape-recorded. Verbatim transcripts o
f these speech samples were scored, while unaware of the personal or f
amily diagnoses of the subjects, using the Thought Disorder Index (TDI
). Results: The mean TDI scores were significantly higher in schizophr
enic than in control adoptees and in biological relatives of the schiz
ophrenic adoptees than in the biological relatives of the control adop
tees, whereas the respective groups of adoptive relatives did not diff
er significantly. The differences were most marked for the samples of
biological sibs and half sibs, which were larger and more representati
ve than the samples of parents. Conclusion: Results suggest that the e
levated TDI scores in the relatives of persons with schizophrenia that
have been found in other studies reflect the operation of genes incre
asing the liability for schizophrenia, rather than the rearing experie
nces that were shared in common with schizophrenic probands.