S. Ungar et al., STRATEGIES FOR KNOWLEDGE ACQUISITION FROM CARTOGRAPHIC MAPS BY BLIND AND VISUALLY-IMPAIRED ADULTS, Cartographic Journal, 34(2), 1997, pp. 93-110
Two experiments are reported both of which employed a research design
originally used by Thorndyke and Stasz (1980) to elicit the spontaneou
s strategies of map readers, and to relate these to their skill in map
reading. In Experiment 1, blind, visually impaired and sighted childr
en explored a tactile or a print map while ''thinking aloud''. The pro
tocols obtained were analysed according to a set of strategy types. Th
e children were also asked to produce a copy of the map to test their
knowledge of it. These were rated according to accuracy. Experiment 2
used the same basic procedure with blind, visually impaired and sighte
d adults, who explored a more complex town map and plan of a building.
Sighted participants produced more accurate copies of the map, and us
ed strategies that focused on global spatial relations on the map, whi
le blind and visually impaired participants tended to focus on individ
ual localised elements of the map. However, those blind and visually i
mpaired participants who produced more accurate copies of the maps, te
nded also to adopt a more global focus.