Dl. Weinstein et al., DIFFERENTIAL EARLY INTERACTIONS BETWEEN SALMONELLA-ENTERICA SEROVAR TYPHI AND 2 OTHER PATHOGENIC SALMONELLA SEROVARS WITH INTESTINAL EPITHELIAL-CELLS, Infection and immunity, 66(5), 1998, pp. 2310-2318
Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi (hereafter referred to as S. typhi)
is a host-restricted pathogen that adheres to and invades the distal i
leum and subsequently disseminates to cause typhoid fever in humans. H
owever, S. typhi appears to be avirulent in small animals. In contrast
, other pathogenic salmonellae, such as S. enterica serovars Typhimuri
um and Dublin (S. typhimurium and S. dublin, respectively), typically
cause localized gastroenteritis in humans hut have been used as models
for typhoid fever because these organisms cause a disease in suscepti
ble rodents that resembles human typhoid. In vivo, S. typhi has been d
emonstrated to attach to and invade murine M cells but is rapidly clea
red from the Peyer's patches without destruction of the hi cells. In c
ontrast, invasion of M cells by S. typhimurium is accompanied by destr
uction of these M cells and subsequently sloughing of the epithelium.
These data have furthered our view that the early steps in the pathoge
nesis of typhoidal and nontyphoidal Salmonella serovars are distinct,
To extend this concept, we have utilized an in vitro model to evaluate
three parameters of initial host-pathogen interactions: adherence of
three Salmonella serovars to human and murine small intestinal epithel
ial cell (IEC) lines, the capacity of these salmonellae to invade IECs
, and the ability of the bacteria to induce interleukin-6 (IL-6) in th
ese cell lines as a measure of host cell activation and the host acute
-phase response, The results demonstrate that S. typhi adheres to and
invades human small IECs better than either S. typhimurium or S. dubli
n. Interestingly, invA and invE null mutants of S. typhi are able neit
her to adhere to nor to invade IECs, unlike S. typhimurium invA anal i
nvE mutants, which adhere to bent cannot invade IECs, S. typhi also in
duces significantly greater quantities of IL-6 in human small IEC line
s than either of the other two Salmonella serovars. These findings sug
gest that differential host cytokine responses to bacterial pathogens
may play an important role in the pathological sequelae that follow in
fection. Importantly, S. typhimurium did Plot induce IL-6 in murine IE
Cs. Since S. typhimurium infection in mice is often used as a model of
typhoid fever, these findings suggest that, at least in this case, th
e mouse model does not reflect the human disease. Taken together, our
studies indicate that (i) marked differences occur in the initial step
s of S. typhi, S. typhimurium, and S. dublin pathogenesis, and (ii) co
nclusions about S. typhi pathogenesis that have been drawn from the mo
use model of typhoid fever should be interpreted conservatively.