T. Elliott et Nr. Shadbolt, NEUROTROPHIC FACTORS, NEURONAL SELECTIONISM, AND NEURONAL PROLIFERATION, Behavioral and brain sciences, 20(4), 1997, pp. 561
Quartz & Sejnowski (A&S) disregard evidence that suggests that their v
iew of dendrites is inadequate and they ignore recent results concerni
ng the role of neurotrophic factors in synaptic remodelling. They misr
epresent neuronal selectionism and thus erect a straw-man argument. Fi
nally, the results discussed in section 4.2 require neuronal prolifera
tion, but this does not occur during the period of neuronal developmen
t of relevance here.