Only one eddy is present in the island wake in the lee of Rattray Isla
nd, a 1600 m wide island in shallow coastal waters off Australia. This
observation is contrary to the predictions of a number of two- and th
ree-dimensional, fixed grid, numerical models which all predict that t
wo eddies are present, one eddy being shed from each of the two tips o
f the island. The discrete vortex model suggests this observation resu
lts from the frictional effects in sub-grid scale details of the topog
raphy close to the tips of the island. This model also successfully re
produces the observations of a Karman vortex street in the lee of isla
nds in Rupert Bay, Canada. By contrast, fixed-grid models predict no s
uch eddy shedding. Island wakes are thus sensitive to details of the b
athymetry near the separation points and these must be either paramete
rized in fixed grid models, whether regular or boundary fitted, or exp
licitly calculated in non-fixed grid models such as the discrete vorte
x model. (C) 1998 Academic Press Limited.