Fractures of the fifth metacarpal can be treated non-operatively by pl
aster immobilisation or functional taping. Ill order to evaluate the b
etter treatment policy, the two methods were compared in a prospective
randomised series. We treated 25 patients with an ulnar gutter plaste
r-cast splintage and 25 with functional tape. Functional recovery was
evaluated after one week and four weeks, three months and sir months.
Mobility, power-grip, pulling-and torque strengths were measured. The
change ill fracture angulation was calculated at the ol re and four-we
ek follow-up. Residual symptoms were evaluated after sir months. The f
unctional tape group showed significant earlier functional recovery. A
fter six months, there were no significant differences between the gro
ups with regard to functional and anatomical results or the number of
patients with residual symptoms. In both groups, toe noted a change in
fracture angulation only in those fractures that had been reduced. We
conclude that fractures of the 5th metacarpal nle better treated by f
unctional taping than by cast immobilisation. (C) 1998 Elsevier Scienc
e Ltd. All rights reserved.