M. Perinotto et al., HYDRODYNAMICAL MODELS OF PLANETARY-NEBULAE AND THE PROBLEM OF ABUNDANCE DETERMINATIONS, Astronomy and astrophysics, 332(3), 1998, pp. 1044-1054
The problem of the accuracy that can be attained in the derivation of
chemical abundances in Planetary Nebulae (PNe) with the best technique
s of the ''constant T-e, n(e)'' type currently in use, has been consid
ered. This has been done by constructing two sequences (A, B) of radia
tion-hydrodynamical PNe models under the framework of the interacting
stellar-winds theory which are intended to represent real planetaries
in different evolutionary stages. Both sequences evolve along the 0.60
5 M. stellar evolutionary track of Blocker (1995b), but start from dif
ferent initial conditions. Corresponding equilibrium models were also
computed for a number of specific models along the stellar track to ob
tain an estimate of the errors that would result from stationary PNe m
odels. The line intensities calculated from these models are interpret
ed under the scheme of the ''constant T-e, n(e)'' method and the deriv
ed elemental abundances are compared with the original input values. T
he obtained deviations vary for the different elements. In the optical
ly thin cases the discrepancies between the abundances derived using t
he ''constant T-e, n(e)'' method and the corresponding input values am
ount to less than 10% for helium and to maximum factors of 1.5 to 3 fo
r oxygen, nitrogen, neon and argon. The discrepancy is higher for sulp
hur, reaching an order of magnitude in the most excited models. Partic
ular attention has to be given to optically thick models. It is found
that the ''constant T-e, n(e)'' method can yield rather erroneous resu
lts in these cases. Only minor deviations are found between abundances
calculated from the hydrodynamical models and those in equilibrium.