This paper studies the quantitative impact of eliminating capital inco
me taxation on capital accumulation and steady-state welfare in a gene
ral equilibrium model with overlapping generations of 65-period-lived
individuals who face idiosyncratic earnings risk, borrowing constraint
s, and life-span uncertainty. Under a wide range of parameter configur
ations, the capital income tax rate that maximizes steady-state welfar
e is positive, even though eliminating it completely would raise the s
teady-state capital stock toward the Golden Rule. This is because the
tax burden is shifted toward the younger and liquidity constrained yea
rs, reducing the individuals' ability to self-insure.