Sd. Gosling et al., DO PEOPLE KNOW-HOW THEY BEHAVE - SELF-REPORTED ACT FREQUENCIES COMPARED WITH ONLINE CODINGS BY OBSERVERS, Journal of personality and social psychology, 74(5), 1998, pp. 1337-1349
Behavioral acts constitute the building blocks of interpersonal percep
tion and the basis for inferences about personality traits. How reliab
ly can observers code the acts individuals perform in a specific situa
tion? How valid are retrospective self-reports of these acts? Particip
ants interacted in a group discussion task and then reported their act
frequencies, which were later coded by observers from videotapes. For
each act, observer-observer agreement, self-observer agreement, and s
elf-enhancement bias were examined. Findings show that (a) agreement v
aried greatly across acts; (b) much of this variation was predictable
from properties of the acts (observability, base rate, desirability, B
ig Five domain); (c) on average, self-reports were positively distorte
d; and (d) this was particularly true for narcissistic individuals. Di
scussion focuses on implications for research on acts, traits, social
perception, and the act frequency approach.