R. Godfrey et M. Davison, EFFECTS OF VARYING SAMPLE-STIMULUS AND CHOICE-STIMULUS DISPARITY ON SYMBOLIC MATCHING-TO-SAMPLE PERFORMANCE, Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 69(3), 1998, pp. 311-326
Six pigeons were trained on a typical two-stimulus two-response symbol
ic matching-to-sample task involving the discrimination of sample and
choice stimuli that were signaled by different probabilities that pixe
ls in an area were lit on a computer screen located behind the respons
e keys. The disparities of the sample and choice stimuli were systemat
ically varied across five experimental parts by manipulating the proba
bilities of pixel illumination. Across conditions within parts, the ra
tio of reinforcers obtainable for matching responses was varied over f
ive levels. A recent model of detection based on the discriminability
between the stimulus-response relations and between response-reinforce
r relations provided an effective description of the data. Consistent
with this model, changes in the disparity of the sample stimuli led to
decreases in stimulus-response discriminability and left response-rei
nforcer discriminability unchanged. Equally, changes in choice-stimulu
s disparity caused a decrease in estimates of response-reinforcer disc
riminability and not in stimulus-response discriminability. Parameter
invariance was thus obtained, and the variables expected to affect the
se parameters (sample and choice stimulus disparity) were correctly id
entified. The reasons for the failure of two recently reported studies
to support parameter invariance under this model are discussed.