M. Szafran et al., ELECTROSTATIC INTERACTIONS AND CONFORMATIONS OF ZWITTERIONIC PYRIDINIUM ALKANOATES, Journal of organic chemistry, 63(9), 1998, pp. 2898-2908
Conformations of flexible zwitterionic omega-pyridinium alkanoates (PB
n) with n methylene units in the tether and their hydrates and hydroch
lorides are studied in the solid state by X-ray diffraction, in aqueou
s solution by FT-IR and H-1, C-13, and N-14 NMR spectroscopies, and in
the gas phase by PM3, SAM1, and DFT calculations. PB1 and PB1 . H2O i
n crystals have a conformation with the N+... O intramolecular distanc
e of ca. 2.7 Angstrom, while PB3 . 2H(2)O and PB10 . 3H(2)O have a tra
ns-zigzag conformation and are arranged antiparallel. Structures of is
olated molecules of omega-pyridinium alkanoates (PBn) and their dihydr
ates (PBn . 2H(2)O) and hydrochlorides (PBn . HCl) optimized using the
PM3, SAM1, and DFT methods are significantly different from those obs
erved in the crystals. In crystals, when n greater than or equal to 2,
as a result of electrostatic interactions in the crystal lattice, the
positively charged center (N+ atom) interacts with negative carboxyl
groups, water molecules, or chloride ions of the neighboring molecules
(intermolecular charge compensation), while in the gas phase only wit
h their own (intramolecular charge compensation). In aqueous solutions
, similarly as in the crystalline state, distances between the charged
centers increase monotonically with increasing number of methylene un
its in the tether. The H-1 and C-13 NMR data suggest that polymethylen
e chains in PBn contain more folded (gauche) conformations than do sod
ium salts of carboxylic acids without a charged N+ atom. The SCRF calc
ulations predict slightly longer N+... C-c distances than those derive
d by Chevalier and Perchec for trimethylammonium carboxylates from C-1
3 NMR spectra. This suggests that the SCRF model underestimates contri
bution of the gauche conformers in aqueous solutions.