INFANT ABUSE AND NEGLECT IN MONKEYS - A DISCUSSION OF DEFINITIONS, EPIDEMIOLOGY, ETIOLOGY, AND IMPLICATIONS FOR CHILD MALTREATMENT - REPLY TO CICCHETTI (1998) AND MASON (1998)
Ka. Carroll et D. Maestripieri, INFANT ABUSE AND NEGLECT IN MONKEYS - A DISCUSSION OF DEFINITIONS, EPIDEMIOLOGY, ETIOLOGY, AND IMPLICATIONS FOR CHILD MALTREATMENT - REPLY TO CICCHETTI (1998) AND MASON (1998), Psychological bulletin, 123(3), 1998, pp. 234-237
In response to D. Cicchetti's (1998) and W. A. Mason's (1998) commenta
ries, this article scrutinizes infant maltreatment in monkeys and its
public health implications. Studies of infant abuse and neglect in mon
keys have used operational definitions based on (a) adult behavior or
(b) adult behavior and infant outcome (depending on data available for
analysis). Direct comparisons between the incidence of maltreatment i
n monkey and human populations can be only tentative as a result of di
fferences in operational definitions of maltreatment. A simplified ver
sion of the ecological-transactional model of maltreatment can be used
in research with nonhuman primates, and different species can be used
to model different aspects of the human phenomenon. Although abuse an
d neglect take different forms in animals and humans, research with an
imal models can make an important contribution to elucidating the adap
tive function, if any, of child maltreatment and the proximate mechani
sms underlying its occurrence.