Cs. North et al., THE ASSOCIATION OF PSYCHIATRIC-DIAGNOSIS WITH WEATHER CONDITIONS IN ALARGE URBAN HOMELESS SAMPLE, Social psychiatry and psychiatric epidemiology, 33(5), 1998, pp. 206-210
Assessment of psychiatric disorders encounters unique complexities in
homeless populations. Although the use of structured diagnostic instru
ments has significantly-improved research methodology in this area, qu
estions remain about the validity of using cross-sectional diagnostic
methods derived from studies of more general populations, In particula
r, the validity of structured diagnostic instruments in the assessment
of schizophrenia, depression, drug use disorder, and antisocial perso
nality disorder (ASPD) in homeless populations has been questioned. Th
e purpose of this stud. was to examine the association of psychiatric
diagnoses with the weather. It was hypothesized that self-report of ps
ychiatric illness may be affected by prevailing weather conditions. Ni
ne hundred homeless subjects randomly sampled from St. Louis shelters,
day centers, and unsheltered locations were interviewed over a 1-year
period. Official average daily temperature and amount of precipitatio
n on the da of each subject's interview were compared with lifetime an
d current psychiatric diagnoses ascertained by the Diagnostic Intervie
wed Schedule. Similar analyses were performed in general population da
ta from the Epidemiologic Catchment Area study. The study found that a
mong homeless men, inclement weather on the day of interview was assoc
iated with lifetime and current diagnoses of major depression. lifetim
e drug use disorder, lifetime diagnosis of ASPD, and curl-ent alcohol
use disorder. These findings, however, were not present in homeless wo
men and not reflected in the general population. The results, although
limited, suggest that weather may confound cross-sectional, standardi
zed methods of psychiatric diagnosis in homeless men. Weather-related
factors among homeless men are associated with ascertainment of both l
ifetime and current diagnosis of major depression, as well as lifetime
drug List disorder and ASPD and current alcohol use disorder. Possibl
e interpretations of these findings are discussed, with implications f
or intervention strategies for psychiatric disorders in the larger con
text of homelessness and social problems.