DEVELOPMENT OF AN INDICATOR TO EVALUATE THE IMPACT, ON A COMMUNITY-BASED AEDES-AEGYPTI CONTROL INTERVENTION, OF IMPROVED CLEANING OF WATER-STORAGE CONTAINERS BY HOUSEHOLDERS
Ast. Chan et al., DEVELOPMENT OF AN INDICATOR TO EVALUATE THE IMPACT, ON A COMMUNITY-BASED AEDES-AEGYPTI CONTROL INTERVENTION, OF IMPROVED CLEANING OF WATER-STORAGE CONTAINERS BY HOUSEHOLDERS, Annals of tropical medicine and parasitology, 92(3), 1998, pp. 317-329
Householders in a community-based programme to control dengue in El Pr
ogreso, Honduras, are being encouraged to improve the cleaning of the
water-storage containers in which many of the vectors thrive. The obje
ctive of the present study was to develop an indicator of the change o
ccurring in human behaviour. Traditional Aedes aegypti larval indices
do not differentiate between containers in which all the immature stag
es are present and those which hold only first- and second-instar larv
ae. However, it is not essential to prevent all larval development to
limit transmission of pathogens by the adults; if the Ae. aegypti in t
he containers only manage to develop to young larvae before the contai
ners are cleaned, then control of the vector in these containers will
be effective. In field trials, sampling of third- and fourth-instar la
rvae in washbasins by taking five dips (quick immersions to a standard
depth) with a hand-held net was found to be sufficient for estimating
the true population size of that same cohere. This sampling method wa
s then included in a large-scale survey of households, conducted for p
rogramme monitoring. An index was then developed as a summary measure
of the degree of infestation of a washbasin by Ae. aegypti. This index
was the sum of four variables assessed in the survey: presence of any
immature stages (larvae and/or pupae); presence of pupae; detection o
f third-fourth-instar larvae in a five-dip sample; and a log-transform
ation of the number of larvae recovered. Based on this new index, the
884 washbasins encountered in the survey were classified as infestatio
n-free (76.2%), or with low- (6.7%), medium- (14.9%) or high-level (2.
2%) infestation. Application of the same procedure to 240 drums encoun
tered in the survey showed that 66.3% were infestation-free and 9.2%,
17.1% and 7.4% had low-, medium- and high-level infestations, respecti
vely. Compared with the traditional indices, this new index should be
more sensitive to changes in human behaviour resulting from a control
programme exposure than a simple, dichotomous variable (i.e. positive/
negative for presence of immature stages). The use of such an index co
uld make the control programme more efficient, allowing the greatest e
fforts to be targeted at households that have medium-high levels of in
festation.