J. Cairns, EXCESSIVE INDIVIDUALISM TODAY THREATENS LIBERTY TOMORROW - SUSTAINABLE USE OF THE PLANET, Population and environment, 19(5), 1998, pp. 397-409
In no period of human history has the exercise of perceived individual
rights been so extreme, especially in developed countries such as the
United States. These perceived rights might have been tolerable in a
frontier society (although it is questionable whether the exercise of
perceived individual rights to overhunt was tolerated) with vast per c
apita resources and space, but not on a planet where resources are bei
ng fully (or over) utilized, billions are malnourished, and the range
from the poorest to the most affluent in material and energy terms is
the greatest in human history. Sustainable use of the planet requires
some curtailment of individual rights as they are now perceived, not o
nly for the well-being of future generations but for more equitability
and fairness at present. In short, sustainability requires a new etho
s (a set of guiding beliefs) substantively different from the current
practices: (1) an intergenerational equity and fairness in the use of
the planet's ecological life support system, (2) an intolerance of the
possible high risk associated with human practices that may result fr
om seriously altering the ecological life support system when the cons
equences of doing so are highly uncertain, and (3) a compassion and es
teem for other species and other humans who are now living or yet to l
ive-this should result from tempering often aggressive insistence on i
ndividual rights.