FROM SNAPSHOTS TO VIDEOTAPE - NEW DIRECTIONS IN RESEARCH ON GENDER DIFFERENCES

Authors
Citation
S. Riger, FROM SNAPSHOTS TO VIDEOTAPE - NEW DIRECTIONS IN RESEARCH ON GENDER DIFFERENCES, Journal of social issues, 53(2), 1997, pp. 395-408
Citations number
41
Categorie Soggetti
Social Issues
Journal title
ISSN journal
00224537
Volume
53
Issue
2
Year of publication
1997
Pages
395 - 408
Database
ISI
SICI code
0022-4537(1997)53:2<395:FSTV-N>2.0.ZU;2-T
Abstract
This article identifies five answers to the question of whether there are sex differences in abilities and personality traits: the ''sociobi ology'' argument, the ''differently situated'' argument, the ''conting ent'' argument, the ''no differences'' argument, and the ''disadvantag e, not difference ''argument, The multiplicity of arguments about sex differences derives from contrasting research paradigms in psychology, The individual differences model, stemming from the early days of sci entific psychology, assumes a radical individualism in which mental ab ilities are made up of stable and unalterable individual characteristi cs that are not influenced by social factors; these characteristics ar e easily captured by quick, one-time, ''snapshot'' research methods. I n contrast, the social psychological model considers the individual to be embedded in and influenced by the social situation. This article p oints out shortcomings of both models for the study of sex differences , and advocates instead a multi-level approach that considers both mic ro-and macro-level factors in shaping the behavior of both females and males. Videotape as a metaphor suggests new ways of thinking about re search on women's lives.