Gh. Mcintosh et al., A DIET CONTAINING CHICKPEAS AND WHEAT OFFERS LESS PROTECTION AGAINST COLON TUMORS THAN A CASEIN AND WHEAT DIET IN DIMETHYLHYDRAZINE-TREATEDRATS, The Journal of nutrition, 128(5), 1998, pp. 804-809
We examined the influence of extruded chickpeas and wheat relative to
casein and wheat in a dimethylhydrazine (DMH)-induced colon tumor stud
y in male Sprague-Dawley rats. The three diets, based on a modified AI
N76 rodent diet with fat present at 10 g/100 g dry matter (DM), were a
s follows: casein with wheat starch (Cas/S) as control, casein with wh
eat (Cas/W) and chickpeas with wheat (CP/W). All diets were fed from 5
wk of age throughout the 28-wk study. At 28 wk, there was a significa
ntly lower incidence of large intestinal tumors in rats fed Cas/W rela
tive to those fed CP/W (11 vs. 56%, chi-square test, P = 0.018). The c
olonic tumor burden (tumors/tumor-bearing animal) was not different in
Cas/W-fed and CP/W-fed rats (1 vs. 1.7), but the tumor mass index was
significantly lower in the former group (0.22 vs. 1.21, P = 0.026). R
ats fed the CP/W diet had significantly lower plasma cholesterol conce
ntration (P < 0.01) than rats fed the other two diets. The cecal conte
nts of rats fed the CP/W diet had significantly greater relative weigh
ts (46%, P < 0.05) than those of the Cas/W-fed rats; this was associat
ed with higher concentrations of all short-chain fatty acids. Fecal an
alyses showed significantly (P < 0.05) higher concentrations of total
fat (54%), total steroids (83%) and secondary bile acids (179%) in the
CP/W-fed rats relative those fed Cas/W. There were higher concentrati
ons of nitrogen in the feces of CP/W rats relative to the Cas/W-fed ra
ts (84%, P < 0.05), associated with greater fecal weights (67%, P < 0.
05). Although wheat and its fibers have been shown to be protective ag
ainst DMH-induced cancers in rats, this was not the case in this study
in which chickpeas (45 g/100 g diet) provided the protein and were an
important source of soluble fiber. Elevated fat, secondary bile acid
concentrations and/or nitrogenous compounds could be responsible for t
he increased colon tumorigenesis seen and may reflect a legume effect.