P. Zbinden et al., PRGEN - PSEUDORECEPTOR MODELING USING RECEPTOR-MEDIATED LIGAND ALIGNMENT AND PHARMACOPHORE EQUILIBRATION, Quantitative structure-activity relationships, 17(2), 1998, pp. 122-130
Based on the structures of known ligand molecules, a pseudoreceptor mo
deling concept developed at our laboratory allows the construction of
a peptidic binding-site model for a structurally uncharacterized biore
gulator. Such a three-dimensional receptor surrogate - validated using
an external set of test compounds - should be able to semi-quantitati
vely predict the binding affinities of related molecules. To reduce pr
oblems resulting from the mutual obscuring of functional groups within
a pharmacophore hypothesis, we have devised a procedure referred to a
s receptor-mediated ligand alignment. It permits to identify an altern
ate position, orientation and conformation for each ligand molecule by
means of conformational search within a primordial receptor model, co
nstructed about the most potent ligands of a series. To derive an ener
getically relaxed model with a high correlation between calculated and
experimental Gee energies of ligand binding, we have developed a liga
nd equilibration protocol. During this iterative procedure, the recept
or surrogate and the pharmacophore are allowed to relax individually,
with and without correlation-coupled energy minimization, respectively
, until a high correlation is achieved in a relaxed state. In our appr
oach (software PrGen), free energies of ligand binding are estimated b
ased on ligand-pseudoreceptor interactions using a directional force f
ield, ligand desolvation energy and the change of both ligand-internal
energy and ligand entropy upon receptor binding. The concept was test
ed by generating and evaluating a pseudoreceptor for the cannabinoid r
eceptor. The binding-site surrogate for this system was constructed ab
out a pharmacophore comprising 18 cannabinoid antagonists. It consists
of 26 amino-acid residues and is capable of predicting free energies
of ligand binding, Delta G degrees, for an external set of 10 test mol
ecules to within 0.8 kcal/mol (RMS) of their experimental value, corre
sponding to an uncertainty factor of 4 in the binding affinity. Maxima
l individual errors of predicted binding affinities do not exceed a fa
ctor of 12.