USE OF THE STRATIFIED PETERSEN ESTIMATOR IN FISHERIES-MANAGEMENT - ESTIMATING THE NUMBER OF PINK-SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS-GORBUSCHA) SPAWNERS IN THE FRASER-RIVER
Cj. Schwarz et Cg. Taylor, USE OF THE STRATIFIED PETERSEN ESTIMATOR IN FISHERIES-MANAGEMENT - ESTIMATING THE NUMBER OF PINK-SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS-GORBUSCHA) SPAWNERS IN THE FRASER-RIVER, Canadian journal of fisheries and aquatic sciences, 55(2), 1998, pp. 281-296
The simple-Petersen estimator is a well-known mark-recapture method to
estimate animal abundance. Two key assumptions are equal catchability
in both samples and complete mixing of tagged and untagged animals. I
f these are violated, severe bias can occur. The stratified-Petersen e
stimator can be used to account for some of the heterogeneity in catch
ability or mixing. In this paper, we first review recent developments
in the stratified-Petersen experiment for fisheries audiences and demo
nstrate some of the practical problems that can occur that have not be
en discussed in the theoretical literature. Second, we present a case
study to estimate the gross escapement of Fraser River pink salmon (On
corhynchus gorbuscha) in 1991. The motivation for this study is a disc
repancy of over 5 million fish between the estimates as derived by the
Pacific Salmon Commission (PSC) (7.5 million fish based on a hydroaco
ustic method) and the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO), Canada
(13.0 million fish based on a mark-recapture method). One hypothesis
put forward was that the discrepancy may be due to the use of a pooled
-Petersen estimator when there is differential migration over time. Th
e stratified-Petersen model suggests that little of this discrepancy c
an be explained by differential migration.