Gr. Riviere et Ta. Derouen, ASSOCIATION OF ORAL SPIROCHETES FROM PERIODONTALLY HEALTHY SITES WITHDEVELOPMENT OF GINGIVITIS, Journal of periodontology, 69(4), 1998, pp. 496-501
THE PURPOSE OF THIS INVESTIGATION was to determine whether the presenc
e of selected disease-associated bacteria in health-associated plaque
correlated with future gingivitis. Sites of periodontal health were id
entified in 65 adults. Six months later (recall 1) plaque was collecte
d from sites that remained in periodontal health, and 5 species of spe
cific bacteria and pathogen-related oral spirochetes were detected usi
ng monoclonal antibodies in a microscopic assay. Members of the spiroc
hete morphogroup were also identified by phase contrast microscopy. Th
e relationship between site-specific detection of bacteria at recall 1
and development of gingivitis at recall 2 or 3 was evaluated by means
of logistic regression using generalized estimating equations, from w
hich odds ratios (OR) were estimated. Significance was conservatively
defined as OR > 2.0 and P < 0.05. We found that 488 of 1,424 healthy s
ites developed gingivitis over the 12-month interval between recall 1
and 3. Only the spirochete morphogroup (OR = 2.04; P = 0.002) was sign
ificantly associated with the transition from health to gingivitis. Th
e association of Treponema socranskii with future gingivitis was highe
r than expected (OR = 2.27), but the relationship was not statisticall
y significant (P = 0.163). Campylobacter rectus, Eikenella corrodens,
Porphyromonas gingivalis, and pathogen-related oral spirochetes did no
t correlate well with gingivitis (OR < 2.0). Health-associated plaque
from 5 sites contained Treponema denticola, and all 5 sites progressed
to gingivitis. An OR could not be calculated because T. denticola was
not detected in health-associated plaque from stable healthy sites. T
hese findings indicated that the presence of T. denticola and unidenti
fied spirochetes in health-associated plaque was associated with incre
ased susceptibility to gingival inflammation. Future studies assessing
a larger panel of dental plaque microorganisms, with shorter interval
s between baseline and follow-up assessment, are necessary to more ful
ly evaluate the association between detection of specific organisms at
healthy sites and risk for gingivitis.