Sw. Marshall et al., FATAL RESIDENTIAL FIRES - WHO DIES AND WHO SURVIVES, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 279(20), 1998, pp. 1633-1637
Context.-The United States has one of the highest fire fatality rates
in the developed world, and three quarters of these deaths are in resi
dential fires. Objective.-To compare characteristics of those who die
and those who survive in the same residential fire. Design.-Data on fa
tal residential fires were collected from the medical examiner and int
erviews with local fire officials. Setting.-North Carolina. Subjects.-
Persons in residential fires with at least 1 fatality in a 1-year peri
od. Main Outcome Measure.-Dying vs surviving a fatal residential fire
that occurred with more than 1 person at home. Results.-Of the 190 dec
edents, 124 (65%) were male, 78 (41%) were home alone, and 69 (53%) of
130 adults who had blood alcohol measured were intoxicated (blood alc
ohol content >22 mmol/L [100 mg/dL]). Of the 254 persons present durin
g fires in which more than 1 person was at home, 112 died. Individuals
more likely to die thigh-vulnerability group) were younger than 5 yea
rs or 64 years or older, had a physical or cognitive disability, or we
re impaired by alcohol or other drugs (risk of death for group, odds r
atio [OR], 4.01; 95% confidence interval [CI], 2.29-7.03). The presenc
e of an adult with no physical or cognitive disabilities who was unimp
aired by alcohol or other drugs (a potential rescuer) reduced the risk
of death in the high-vulnerability group (OR, 0.49; 95% CI, 0.24-0.99
) but not the low-vulnerability group. Overall, a functioning smoke de
tector lowered the risk of death (OR, 0.39; 95% CI, 0.18-0.83). Conclu
sions.-Smoke detectors were equally effective in both low-and high-vul
nerability populations. The high-vulnerability group was more likely t
o survive if, in addition to a smoke detector, a potential rescuer was
present. Further research should seek to identify prompts that facili
tate speedy egress from a burning structure and that can be incorporat
ed into residential fire alarm systems.