A program was undertaken to apply the ASTM E 1221 test method to two s
ubmarine steels exhibiting high ratios of toughness to yield stress. T
he objective was to measure the capacities of these steels and represe
ntative shipyard welds to arrest fast running cracks. Although the met
hod is not a measure of dynamic toughness, it was considered to be a p
rocedure capable of comparing the crack arresting abilities of these s
teels. The work has shown that it is possible to follow ASTM E 1221 an
d obtain valid crack arrest fracture toughness results for materials w
ith room temperature K-Jc as high as 240 MPa root m and a yield stress
of 690 MPa using specimens of 50-mm thickness. The process did, howev
er, have a high level of unreliability, necessitating a large number o
f tests and extensive re-testing to obtain valid results. Test tempera
tures below -60 degrees C were required to obtain run-arrest events, a
nd as such could not easily be related to material qualification proce
dures such as explosion bulge testing or to submarine operating temper
atures.