Objectives, Renal cell carcinomas often show a high degree of resistan
ce to chemotherapy and radiation despite expressing normal function of
the protein p53. The loss of control of apoptosis may also contribute
to progression and resistance to treatment modalities and can be attr
ibuted to an interaction between p53 and the apoptotic regulators bcl-
2 and Bax. To determine whether the expression of p53, bcl-2, or Bar c
ould be correlated with outcome, we analyzed the expression pattern of
these proteins in renal cell tumor samples, Methods. We examined 28 p
atients with clear cell renal cell carcinomas along with 7 patients wi
th papillary renal cell carcinomas and 4 with renal oncocytomas. All r
enal cell carcinomas were clinically localized Stage pT2 with tumor si
ze ranging from 4.0 to 10.3 cm (mean 6.23). Immunohistochemistry was p
erformed on all samples and correlated with markers of outcome, includ
ing tumor grade, metastasis, recurrence, and overall survival rate. Re
sults. In all clear cell tumors, the detection level of p53 expression
was below the sensitivity of the assay, consistent with the reported
infrequent incidence of p53 mutations in renal cell cancers. bcl-2 exp
ression showed a significant correlation (P = 0.018) with higher tumor
grade but could not be significantly correlated with other parameters
examined including tumor recurrence, metastasis, or survival rate. Th
e expression of Bar could similarly be correlated with higher tumor gr
ade but with none of the other parameters. Conclusions. At the present
time, the combination of both tumor grade and stage represents the be
st prognostic markers available. Adjunctive use of bcl-2 and Bar stain
ing currently plays a minimal role in helping to further stratify pati
ents at high risk for disease progression or recurrence. (C) 1998, Els
evier Science Inc. All rights reserved.