R. Stegmann et G. Frenking, MECHANISM OF THE ACETYLENE-VINYLIDENE REARRANGEMENT IN THE COORDINATION SPHERE OF A TRANSITION-METAL, Organometallics, 17(10), 1998, pp. 2089-2095
Quantum mechanical calculations at the CCSD(T) level of theory using B
P86-optimized geometries indicate that the high-valent d(0) tungsten a
cetylene complex [F2W(HCCH)] (1) is 10.4 kcal/mol lower in energy than
the isomeric vinylidene complex [F4W(CCH2)] (2). Two energetically hi
gh-lying reaction pathways are calculated for the tautomerization reac
tion 1 --> 2. The direct 1,2-hydrogen migration has a barrier of 84.8
kcal/mol and proceeds via the transition state TS1, which has a nonpla
nar C2H2 moiety. TS1 resembles the transition states for the rearrange
ment of the free C2H2 species in the triplet state and as an anion. Th
e alternative rearrangement involves the alkynyl(hydrido) complex 3 as
an intermediate, which is 50.5 kcal/mol higher in energy than 1. The
rate-determining step of the two-step process 1 --> 3 --> 2 is the 1,3
-hydrogen migration 3 --> 2, which has an energy barrier of 85.5 kcal/
mol with respect to 1. The high barriers for the two alternative pathw
ays of the tautomerization reaction 1 --> 2 make it unlikely that they
play a role in the acetylene polymerization reaction, which is cataly
zed by high-valent transition-metal compounds. The analysis of the bon
ding situation using the NBO and CDA methods show that 1 and 2 should
not be considered as acetylene and vinylidene complexes but rather as
metallacyclopropene and metallaallene, respectively.