The effect of the inclusion of the exact exchange into self-interactio
n corrected generalized gradient approximation density functional theo
ry (GGA-DFT) for the simplest hydrogen abstraction reaction, H + (H)2
--> H-3 --> H-2 + H, is presented using a triple-zeta augmented 6-311+G(d,3pd) basis set. The introduction of the self-interaction correcti
on has a considerably larger effect on molecular geometry and vibratio
nal frequencies than the inclusion of the exact exchange. We investiga
te the influence of the self-interaction error on the shape of the pot
ential energy surface around the transition state of the hydrogen abst
raction reaction. The decomposition of the self-interaction error into
correlation and exchange parts shows that the exchange self-interacti
on error is the main component of the energy barrier error. The best a
greements with the experimental barrier height were achieved by self-i
nteraction corrected B3LYP, B-LYP and B3PW functionals with errors of
1.5, 2.9 and 3.0 kcal/mol, respectively.