I examined how the performance of Castilleja wightii (Scrophulariaceae
), a generalist root parasite, is affected by the availability of diff
erent combinations of host species. In this greenhouse study, I focuse
d on pairs of hosts consisting of either two leguminous host individua
ls (Lupinus arboreus; Fabaceae), two non-nitrogen-fixing hosts (Erioph
yllum stachaedifolium; Asteraceae), or one individual of each of these
species. Castilleja growth and reproductive performance were greatly
improved by the simultaneous attack of two distinct host species, even
though Castilleja grown with two Lupinus hosts had significantly high
er nitrogen content. Different combinations of host species also stron
gly affected the growth of aphid colonies feeding on the Castilleja us
ed in this experiment. Across all treatments, the growth of aphid colo
nies was positively correlated with the nitrogen content of the parasi
tic plants, which, in turn depended on the combination of hosts attack
ed. Aphid colonies feeding on parasites attacking a mixture of host sp
ecies grew more slowly than those on parasites attacking two Lupinus i
ndividuals. Therefore, simultaneous attack of a mixture of host specie
s may lead to improved parasite performance in two ways-via a direct b
enefit on parasite growth and flowering as well as a possible indirect
benefit because of the relatively poor performance of herbivores feed
ing on these parasites.