M. Karasawa, ELIMINATING NATIONAL STEREOTYPES - DIRECT VERSUS INDIRECT DISCONFIRMATION OF BELIEFS IN COVARIATION, Japanese psychological research, 40(2), 1998, pp. 61-73
Two modes of disconfirmation of national stereotypes were compared. It
was hypothesized that stereotypes should be revised either by stereot
ype-inconsistent cases from the primary target (i.e., direct disconfir
mation) or by instances which belong to an alternative target but poss
ess features stereotypic of the primary target (indirect disconfirmati
on), it was further predicted that politically liberal individuals wou
ld show greater change in their national stereotypes than conservative
s. Two experiments were conducted in which the salience of directly an
d indirectly disconfirming information regarding different nations was
manipulated. The results indicated that indirect disconfirmation gene
rally had as much impact as direct disconfirmation, but that the effec
ts were particularly visible among liberal participants. Conservatives
tended to respond in a reactive manner which preserved or exaggerated
their original views. A new theoretical framework for the study of st
ereotype change and implications for its application were discussed.