With the creation of the protected area of Cayos Cochinos, a five-year
ban on lobster and conch fishing was implemented by the government of
Honduras (started in November 1993). This study provides an initial a
ssessment of the artisanal fishery carried out within the biological r
eserve exclusively by hook-and-line, and discuss potential influences
of this activity on the recovery of the area. During 11 months, fish l
andings were monitored, through the analysis of a sample of 4959 fishe
s based on 365 questionnaires performed to fishermen, to evaluate the
species composition, the weight and size of the most important species
, the catch per unit effort (CPUE) and the yield from coral reefs with
in the protected area. The most common mean of transportation of fishe
rmen is the canoes without engines (97%), providing a CPUE for the ent
ire Reserve of 5.1 kg/fisher/day distributed in 37 species. About 80%
of the total catch is represented by 8 species (mainly Lutjanidae, Ser
ranidae and Haemulidae). It is concentrated in reef areas closely to t
he fishing villages (ca. 38% of the protected area). Dominant species
caught was the yellow-tail snapper, Ocyurus chrysurus, with 53% of the
total landings, apparently based on a 95% population of juvenile indi
viduals (20-37 cm). We estimate, based on an average record of 23 cano
es/day and our data of 2530 kg/month for fishing landings similar to 2
930 kg/month recorded indirectly from fish-buyers located in the three
villages, a fish yield for the reefs of 0.14 t/km(2)/year for the ree
fs inside Biological Reserve, highly comparable to overfished areas el
sewhere. The results of the present study and the results from other s
tudies on the visual abundance and diversity of fishes, queen conch an
d lobster in this area indicate that a high level of artisanal fishery
exploitation exists within the protected area where the integrity of
populations of commercial and cultural value species are being placed
in danger. The current rate of exploitation of certain species, the hi
gh catch of immature juveniles, the low yield for this fishery, and th
e gradual degradation of natural habitats where important species repr
oduce and grow cannot continue if adequate levels of management is the
goal. The existing fishing regulations have aimed to a positive reduc
tion of the commercial vessel activities, nevertheless, it seems as if
the impact of artisanal fishing has being underestimated within the R
eserve and the collapse of certain species would be expected unless pr
esent regulations are improved.