Mr. Brunetto et al., EFFECT OF INTERFERON-ALPHA ON PROGRESSION OF CIRRHOSIS TO HEPATOCELLULAR-CARCINOMA - A RETROSPECTIVE COHORT STUDY, Lancet, 351(9115), 1998, pp. 1535-1539
Background There is debate about whether interferon-alpha treatment lo
wers the risk of progression to hepatocellular carcinoma in patients w
ith chronic viral hepatitis and cirrhosis and whether any effect is li
mited to certain subgroups. We investigated these issues by retrospect
ive analysis of data for 913 patients from Italy and Argentina. Method
s 21 centres reported patients from their records who had chronic vira
l hepatitis and Child's A cirrhosis, were positive for HBsAg or hepati
tis-C-virus antibodies (anti-HCV), and had been screened yearly for at
least 3 years by ultrasonography and alpha-1-fetoprotein testing. Pro
gnostic risk factors for hepatocellular carcinoma defined by multivari
ate Cox regression analysis and individual observation time were used
for group matching and conditional logistic regression analysis of the
independent interferon-alpha treatment effect. Findings After group m
atching, the number of patients was reduced to 637. Age, male sex, and
portal hypertension were significant risk factors for hepatocellular
carcinoma (each p<0.001); hepatic inflammation (p=0.21) and iron stora
ge (p=0.18) were also included in the model. 66 (19%) of 356 untreated
patients and 29 (10%) of 281 treated patients developed hepatocellula
r carcinoma (relative risk 1.99 [95% CI 1.09-3.64]); the corresponding
proportions for anti-HCV-positive patients were 48 (18.5%) of 259 ver
sus 21 (9.1%) of 232 (3.14 [1.46-6.80]), and those for hepatitis-B-vir
us-infected (HBV) patients were 18 (10%) of 97 and eight (16%) of 49 (
0.98 [0.33-2.92]). Among anti-HCV patients without HBV markers, 29 (20
%) of 129 untreated and six (5%) of 116 treated patients developed hep
atocellular carcinoma (6.28 [1.65-23.8]). Interpretation Interferon tr
eatment lowered the rate of progression to hepatocellular carcinoma tw
o ford. The risk reduction was apparently greater for patients with ch
ronic hepatitis C and no evidence of HBV infection. Future studies sho
uld stratify HCV-infected patients by HBV status.