R. Philipona et al., THE BASE-LINE SURFACE RADIATION NETWORK PYRGEOMETER ROUND-ROBIN CALIBRATION EXPERIMENT, Journal of atmospheric and oceanic technology, 15(3), 1998, pp. 687-696
With the aim of improving the consistency of terrestrial and atmospher
ic longwave radiation measurements within the Baseline Surface Radiati
on Network, five: Eppley Precision Infrared Radiometer (PIR) pyrgeomet
ers and one modified Mereorological Research Flight (MRF) pyrgeometer
were individually calibrated by 11 specialist laboratories. The round-
robin experiment was conducted in a ''blind'' sense in that the partic
ipants had no knowledge of the results of others until the wholl: seri
es of calibrations had ended. The responsivities C(mu V/W m(-2)) deter
mined by 6 of the 11 institutes were within about 2% of the median for
all five PIR pyrgeometers. Among the six laboratories, the absolute d
eviation around the median of the deviations of the five instruments i
s less than 1%. This small scatter suggests that PII: pyrgeometers wer
e stable at least during the two years of the experiment and that the
six different calibration devices reproduce the responsivity C of PIR
pyrgeometers consistently and within the precision required for climat
e applications. The results also suggest that the responsivity C can b
e determined without simultaneous determination of the dome correction
factor k, if the temperature difference between pyrgeometer body and
dome is negligible during calibration. For field measurements, however
, k has to be precisely known. The calibration of the MRF pyrgeometer,
although not performed by all institutes, also showed satisfactory re
sults.