Jm. Neal et al., QUANTITATIVE-ANALYSIS OF RESPIRATORY, MOTOR, AND SENSORY FUNCTION AFTER SUPRACLAVICULAR BLOCK, Anesthesia and analgesia, 86(6), 1998, pp. 1239-1244
The incidence and clinical significance of hemidiaphragmatic paresis a
fter supraclavicular block of the brachial plexus is unknown. Eight he
althy volunteers received a supraclavicular block with a standard tech
nique using 30 mL of 1.5% lidocaine. Respiratory function was assessed
with ultrasound of the diaphragm, respiratory inductive plethysmograp
hy (RIP), and pulmonary function tests (PFT) every 20 min. Sensory blo
ck was assessed with pinprick and motor block with isometric force dyn
amometry every 20 min. Four of eight subjects demonstrated hemidiaphra
gmatic paresis on both ultrasound and RIP. No subject experienced chan
ges in PFT values or subjective symptoms of respiratory difficulty. Mo
tor and sensory blockade outlasted hemidiaphragmatic paresis. These re
sults are contrasted to the often symptomatic, 100% incidence of hemid
iaphragmatic paresis seen after interscalene block. In this study of h
ealthy volunteers, supraclavicular block was associated with a 50% inc
idence (95% confidence interval 14-86) of hemidiaphragmatic paresis th
at was not accompanied by clinical evidence of respiratory compromise.
Implications: Interscalene block is always associated with diaphragma
tic paralysis and respiratory compromise. The significance of these si
de effects after supraclavicular block is unknown. Using sensitive mea
sures of respiratory function, we determined that diaphragmatic paraly
sis occurs less often with the supraclavicular approach and is not ass
ociated with respiratory difficulties in healthy subjects.