Jf. Vansteenkiste et al., LYMPH-NODE STAGING IN NON-SMALL-CELL LUNG-CANCER WITH FDG-PET SCAN - A PROSPECTIVE-STUDY ON 690 LYMPH-NODE STATIONS FROM 68 PATIENTS, Journal of clinical oncology, 16(6), 1998, pp. 2142-2149
Purpose: To compare the accuracy of computed tomography-(CT) scan and
the radiolabeled glucose analog F-18-fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glvcose (FDG) po
sitron emission tomography (PET) visually correlated with CT (PET + CT
) in the locoregional lymph node (LN) staging of non-small-cell lung c
ancer (NSCLC). Patients and Methods: Sixty-eight patients with potenti
ally operable NSCLC underwent thoracic CT, PET, and invasive surgical
staging (155), Imaging studies were read prospectively and blinded to
the surgical and pathologic data. A five-point visual scale was used f
or the interpretation of LNs on PET. Afterwards, with knowledge of the
pathology, the relationship between standardized uptake values (SUVs)
and the presence of metastasis in LNs was explored in a receiver oper
ating characteristic (ROC) analysis, and the likelihood ratios (LRs) f
or SUVs of LNs were determined. Results: ISS was available for 690 LN
stations. CT correctly identified the nodal stage in 40 of 68 patients
(59%), with understaging in 12 patients and overstaging in 16 patient
s. PET + CT was accurate in 59 patients (87%), with understaging in fi
ve patients and overstaging in four patients. In the detection of loca
lly advanced disease (N2/N3), the sensitivity, specificity, and accura
cy of CT were 75%, 63%, and 68%, respectively. for PET + CT, this was
93%, 95%, and 94% (P = .0004). In the ROC curve, the best SUV threshol
d to distinguish benign from malignant LNs was 4.40. The analysis with
this SUV threshold was not superior to the use of a five-point visual
scale. The LR of a SUV less than 3.5 in an LN was 0.152; for a SUV be
tween 3.5 and 4.5, it was 3.157; and for a SUV greater than 4.5, it wa
s 253.096. Conclusion: PET + CT is significantly more accurate than CT
alone in LN staging of NSCLC, A five-point visual scale is as accurat
e as the use of an SUV threshold for LNs in the distinction between be
nign and malignant nodes. The very high negative predictive value of m
ediastinal PET could reduce the need for mediastinal ISS in NSCLC subs
tantially.