Rs. Polin et al., INTRAARTERIALLY ADMINISTERED PAPAVERINE FOR THE TREATMENT OF SYMPTOMATIC CEREBRAL VASOSPASM, Neurosurgery, 42(6), 1998, pp. 1256-1264
OBJECTIVE: We examined the therapeutic benefits of intra-arterially ad
ministered papaverine for treatment of symptomatic cerebral vasospasm
after subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH). Recent advances in microcatheter
technology have facilitated endovascular approaches to vessels experie
ncing vasospasm after SAH. However, despite numerous encouraging anecd
otal reports, no rigorous examination of the efficacy of these procedu
res has been published. Intra-arterial infusion of papaverine has beco
me part of the standard management of vasospasm at some centers. METHO
DS: We examined a series of 31 patients undergoing papaverine infusion
for the treatment of symptomatic vasospasm after SAH. The patients we
re a subgroup of the series enrolled in the North American Trial of Ti
rilizad for Aneurysmal Subarachnoid Hemorrhage. These individuals were
matched with patients from the same trial who exhibited similar clini
cal characteristics (including the degree of vasospasm and the modifie
d Glasgow Coma Scale scores measured at the time of admission and on t
he day of papaverine infusion) but received medical management alone f
or vasospasm. RESULTS: Logistic regression analysis comparing these tw
o groups showed no statistical difference in the 3-month Glasgow Outco
me Scale scores between patients receiving papaverine and control subj
ects (58% favorable outcomes for control subjects versus 45% for patie
nts receiving papaverine). CONCLUSION: Although isolated series docume
nting clinical successes have prompted the increased use of papaverine
as a treatment for vasospasm after SAH, this series suggests that, as
it is currently being used, the drug does not provide added benefits,
compared with medical treatment of vasospasm alone. This result does
not preclude the possibility that alterations in the timing of or indi
cations for drug treatment might produce beneficial effects.