J. Ortiz et al., Infections caused by Escherichia coli resistant to norfloxacin in hospitalized cirrhotic patients, HEPATOLOGY, 29(4), 1999, pp. 1064-1069
Selective intestinal decontamination with norfloxacin is useful to prevent
bacterial infections in several groups of cirrhotic patients at high risk o
f infection. However, the emergence of infections caused by Escherichia col
i resistant to quinolones has recently been observed in cirrhotic patients
undergoing prophylactic norfloxacin. Our aim is to determine the characteri
stics of the infections caused by E. coli resistant to norfloxacin in hospi
talized cirrhotic patients. One hundred and six infections caused by E. col
i in 99 hospitalized cirrhotic patients were analyzed and distributed into
two groups: group I(n = 67), infections caused by E. coli sensitive to norf
loxacin, and group II (n = 39), infections caused by E. coli resistant to n
orfloxacin. The clinical and analytical characteristics at diagnosis of the
infection were similar in both groups. Previous prophylaxis with norfloxac
in was more frequent in group II (15/67, 22.4% vs. 32/39, 82%, P <.0001), a
s a result of a higher number of patients submitted to continuous long-term
prophylaxis in this group, whereas previous short-term prophylaxis was sim
ilar in both groups. Infections were more frequently nosocomial-acquired in
group II than in group I (17/67, 25.3% vs. 20/39, 51.2%, P = .01). The typ
e of infections was similar in both groups: urinary tract infections 38 in
group I and 24 in group II, spontaneous bacterial peritonitis 8 and 2, spon
taneous bacteremia 4 and 4, and bacterascites 1 and 0, respectively (pNS).
Mortality during hospitalization was similar in the two groups (4/67, 5.9%
vs. 5/39, 12.8%, pNS). None of the E. coli resistant to norfloxacin were al
so resistant to cefotaxime and only one of them was resistant to amoxicilli
n-clavulanic acid. Prophylaxis with norfloxacin, usually continuous long-te
rm prophylaxis, favors the development of infections caused by norfloxacin-
resistant E. coli. Long-term antibiotic prophylaxis should therefore be res
tricted to highly selected groups of cirrhotic patients at high-risk of inf
ection. Infections caused by E. call resistant to norfloxacin show a severi
ty similar to those caused by sensitive E. coli. No significant associated
resistance between norfloxacin and the antibiotics most frequently used in
the treatment of bacterial infections in cirrhotic patients has been observ
ed.