Jw. Shervais et Jj. Mcgee, Petrology of the Western Highland Province: Ancient crust formation at theApollo 14 site, J GEO R-PLA, 104(E3), 1999, pp. 5891-5920
Plutonic rocks found at the Apollo 14 site comprise four lithologic suites:
the magnesian suite, the alkali suite, evolved lithologies, and the ferroa
n anorthosite suite (FAN). Rocks of the magnesian suite include troctolite,
anorthosite, norite, dunite, and harzburgite; they are charaterized by pla
gioclase approximate to An(95) and mafic minerals with mg#s 82-92. Alkali s
uite rocks and evolved rocks generally have plagioclase approximate to An(9
0) to approximate to An(40), and mafic minerals with mg#s 82-40. Lithologie
s include anorthosite, norite, quartz monzodiorite, granite, and felsite. F
erroan anorthosites have plagioclase approximate to An(96) and mafic minera
ls with mg#s 45-70. Whole rock geochemical data show that most magnesian su
ite samples and all alkali anorthosites are cumulates with little or no tra
pped liquid component. Norites may contain significant trapped liquid compo
nent, and some alkali norites may represent cumulate-enriched, near-liquid
compositions, similar to KREEP basalt 15386. Evolved lithologies include ev
olved partial cumulates related to alkali suite fractionation (quartz monzo
diorite), immiscible melts derived from these evolved magmas (granites), an
d impact melts of preexisting granite (felsite). Plots of whole rock mg# ve
rsus whole rock Ca/(Ca+Na+K) show a distinct gap between rocks of the magne
sian suite and rocks of the alkali suite, suggesting either distinct parent
magmas or distinct physical processes of formation. Chondrite-normalized r
are earth element (REE) patterns show that rocks of both the magnesian suit
e and alkali suite have similar ranges, despite the large difference in maj
or element chemistry. Current models for the origin of the magnesian suite
call for a komatiitic parent magma derived from early magma ocean cumulates
; these melts must assimilate plagiophile elements to form troctolites at l
ow pressures and must assimilate a highly enriched KREEP component so that
the resulting mixture has REE concentrations similar to high-K KREEP. There
are as yet no plausible scenarios that can explain these unusual requireme
nts. We propose that partial melting of a primitive lunar interior and buff
ering of these melts by ultramagnesian early magma ocean cumulates provides
a more reasonable pathway to form magnesian troctolites. Alkali anorthosit
es and norites formed by crystallization of a parent magma with major eleme
nt compositions similar to KREEP basalt 15386; If the parent magma of the a
lkali suite and evolved rocks is related to the magnesian suite, then that
magma must have evolved through combined assimilation-fractional crystalliz
ation processes to form the alkali suite cumulates.