Since the discovery of the phenomenon of neural induction by Spemann and Ma
ngold in 1924, considerable effort has been invested in identifying the sig
nals produced by the organizer that are responsible for diverting the fate
of cells from epidermal to neural. Substantial progress has been made only
recently by the finding in amphibians that BMP4 is a neural inhibitor and e
pidermal inducer, and that endogenous antagonists of BMPs ate secreted by t
he organizer. However, recent results in the chick point to the existence o
f other, upstream events required before BMP inhibition stabilizes neural f
ates. Here we take a critical view of the evidence far and against the view
that BMP inhibition is a sufficient trigger for neural induction in differ
ent vertebrates.