L. Gaston et al., ALLIANCE, TECHNIQUE, AND THEIR INTERACTIONS IN PREDICTING OUTCOME OF BEHAVIORAL, COGNITIVE, AND BRIEF DYNAMIC THERAPY, Psychotherapy research, 8(2), 1998, pp. 190-209
With depressed elderly patients treated in behavioral (BT), cognitive
(CT) or brief dynamic therapy (BDT), the prediction of outcome by alli
ance, technique (exploratory and supportive), and their interactions w
as examined. The alliance was rated on the CALPAS-R, and technique on
the Inventory of Therapeutic Strategies (ITS). In BT, pretherapy depre
ssion levels and alliance predicted outcome, as did more exploratory i
nterventions provided in the context of poorer alliances at midtherapy
. In CT, alliance and exploratory interventions predicted outcome thro
ughout treatment, as did more exploratory interventions provided in th
e context of poorer alliances at midtherapy. In BDT, some alliance dim
ensions predicted outcome throughout treatment, as did exploratory tec
hniques at midtherapy; furthermore, the use of exploratory interventio
ns in the context of better alliances tended to predict better outcome
s, a finding contrary to the ones observed in BT and CT. Therefore, di
fferential processes were observed across therapy conditions and phase
s.