In spring 1917, Jewish socialist leaders in Smolensk articulated a pol
itics of class based upon a highly politicized ascription of class ide
ntities. Class identity resonated more strongly among Smolensk's Jews
than did the model of Jewish cultural identity offered by non-socialis
t organizations. In July, socialists consolidated their control over l
ocal state institutions. But in later summer labor conflicts and decli
ning living conditions drove a wedge between workers and socialist lea
ders. In a process that paralleled the development of labor politics i
n Russia's largest cities, Smolensk's Jewish socialist leaders were ma
rginalized by their own rhetoric of class struggle. In fall 1917, Jewi
sh workers drifted away from the socialists towards non-socialist Zion
ist organizations, which had developed their own organizational base a
nd established distinct political positions grounded by Jewish cultura
l identity. By contrast, the Jewish socialist parties re flexively res
ponded to events outside their control. After the Bolshevik seizure of
power, Smolensk's Jews fell back upon a pre-revolutionary repertoire
of accommodation to hostile authorities.