The stability and resilience of two very similar soil ecosystems were
challenged over an extended time by organic and conventional managemen
t systems. The responses were compared against a native soil ecosystem
by following carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus balances through the bio
logical, geological, and chemical sub-systems. The types and amounts o
f carbon inputs did not predict the resulting system contents or prope
rties. Nitrogen and phosphorus retained in the systems were related to
, but not proportional to, inputs. Carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus mov
ed through the agroecosystems and excesses were exported to maintain s
tasis in the component sub-systems. A flow diagram was proposed to des
cribe the stabilizing responses in these systems. The unique propertie
s of each agroecosystem must be considered when developing sustainable
management practices. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reser
ved.