In order to evaluate the efficacy of preoperative physical therapy for
patients undergoing elective primary total knee arthroplasty, 10 pati
ents completed 6 weeks of physical therapy before surgery (PT group).
Ten patients served as controls (C group). Subjects were tested at bas
eline (PT only), before surgery, 6 weeks after surgery, and 3 months a
fter surgery using the Hospital for Special Surgery knee rating scale,
range of motion, thigh circumference, walking speed, Cybex Ii isokine
tic knee flexion, and extension testing, and computed tomography scann
ing for cross-sectional muscle area. Hospital stay and need for physic
al therapy after inpatient rehabilitation were also compared. Physical
therapy produced modest gains in isokinetic flexion strength in these
severely arthritic knees but no difference in extension strength. The
decrease in isokinetic strength after surgery was not affected by pre
operative physical therapy. Muscle area did not decrease significantly
for the PT group, but it did decrease for the C group after surgery.
While postoperative strength differences could not be demonstrated, pr
eoperative physical therapy preserved thigh muscle area after surgery.
The clinical significance of this finding is uncertain. Consequently,
this study failed to support the routine use of preoperative physical
therapy in knee replacement surgery.