It has been documented that spleen necrosis virus (SNV) can package mu
rine leukemia virus (MLV) RNA efficiently and propagate MLV vectors to
the same titers as it propagates SNV-based vectors. Although the SNV
packaging signal (E) and MLV packaging signal (Psi) have little sequen
ce homology, similar double-hairpin RNA structures were predicted and
supported by experimental evidence. To test whether SNV RNA can be pac
kaged by MLV proteins, we modified an SNV vector to be expressed in an
MLV-based murine helper cell line. Surprisingly, we found that MLV pr
oteins could not support the replication of SNV vectors. The decrease
in titer was approximately 2,000- to 20,000-fold in one round of retro
viral replication. RNA analysis revealed that SNV RNA was not efficien
tly packaged by MLV proteins. RNA hybridization of the cellular and vi
ral RNAs indicated that SNV RNA was packaged at least 25-fold less eff
iciently than MLV RNA, which was the sensitivity limit of the hybridiz
ation assay. The contrast between the MLV and SNV packaging specificit
y is striking. SNV proteins can recognize both SNV E and MLV Psi, but
MLV can recognize only MLV Psi. This is the first demonstration of two
retroviruses with nonreciprocal packaging specificities.