H. Motherby et al., STATIC DNA CYTOMETRY AS A DIAGNOSTIC-AID IN EFFUSION CYTOLOGY II - DNA ANEUPLOIDY FOR IDENTIFICATION OF NEOPLASTIC-CELLS IN EQUIVOCAL EFFUSIONS, Analytical and quantitative cytology and histology, 20(3), 1998, pp. 162-168
OBJECTIVE: The sensitivity of conventional cytology for identification
of neoplastic cells in effusions is unsatisfactory, about 58%. The ra
te of diagnostically equivocal effusions in routine cytology is about
6%. DNA aneuploidy has previously been proven to be a sensitive and sp
ecific marker for the identification of tumor cells in effusions. In t
he present study we determined if malignancy can be identified in cyto
logically equivocal cells in effusions using DNA aneuploidy as a marke
r, thus decreasing the rate of cytologically equivocal diagnoses in ef
fusions. STUDY DESIGN: One hundred cytologically equivocal effusions o
f the serous cavities were obtained from routine diagnostic material.
Nuclear DNA content was measured after Feulgen staining using a TV ima
ge analysis system. Data were correlated with patient follow-up. RESUL
TS: DNA aneuploidy was assumed if abnormal DNA stemlines, a coefficien
t of variation of the first DNA stemline greater than or equal to 10%
or cells >9c were observed. The sensitivity of DNA aneuploidy for the
identification of malignancy was 55.9%. Specificity of DNA nonaneuploi
dy for benignity was 94.1%. The positive predictive value of the marke
r DNA aneuploidy for the occurrence of malignant cells was 97.9% since
all but one DNA aneuploid case showed malignancy in follow-up. CONCLU
SION: Image cytometry applying DNA aneuploidy as a parameter is able t
o detect the occurrence of malignant cells in cytologically equivocal
effusions in about every second case. Thus, this method is able to inc
rease diagnostic accuracy of conventional effusion cytology by decreas
ing the rate of diagnostically equivocal effusions.