Jr. Rodrigue et al., PERCEPTIONS OF LIVER-TRANSPLANT CANDIDATES WITH OR WITHOUT AN ALCOHOL-USE HISTORY, Journal of clinical psychology in medical settings, 5(2), 1998, pp. 199-211
Cirrhosis secondary to alcohol use is a primary cause of liver disease
and a medical condition for which liver transplantation is a viable t
reatment option. However there remains considerable debate within both
the lay and the medical communities regarding the distribution of a s
carce medical resource to adults with alcoholism. This study examined
college students' perceptions toward an adult, presented in a written
vignette, for whom liver transplantation was medically indicated. The
influence of gender (female and male) and alcohol use history (no alco
hol history, alcoholism history with long-term abstinence, alcoholism
history with current use) on these ratings was examined. Subjects rate
d the adult presented with no alcohol history more positively than the
y did the adults presented with a history of alcoholism. Also the adul
t with no alcohol history was more likely to be offered transplantatio
n and was given higher priority ratings for transplantation by subject
s. While subjects' own alcohol use history and organ donor registratio
n status were not associated with ratings, having a family member with
an alcohol problem and personally knowing a transplant recipient were
related to more favorable ratings toward the adult presented in the v
ignette. Implications of these findings as well as limitations of the
study are discussed.