In the current debate on the ability of oil emplacement to halt quartz
cementation in sandstone oil reservoirs, this paper supports a 'yes,
it can' answer. Although we find some of the empirical data (petroleum
fluid inclusion abundances, quartz-depth trends) to be inconclusive,
we have made progress in this debate by examining theoretical controls
for three end-member quartz cementation scenarios. (1) Silica externa
lly sourced via advection. Oil emplacement must halt quartz cementatio
n because of the associated massive reduction in relative permeability
to water. (2) Silica supplied internally, water-wet reservoir. Quartz
cementation will be inhibited because the rate of diffusion will be r
educed by orders of magnitude, making diffusion the rate controlling s
tep. The degree of inhibition will depend on rock fabric and oil satur
ation; at very high oil saturations quartz cementation could effective
ly cease. (3) Silica supplied internally, oil-wet reservoir. Quartz ce
mentation will be halted as water cannot access to grain surfaces.