The relative stability of cylindrically imploding shock and detonation
waves has been examined using a two-dimensional numerical model. A se
quence of increasingly realistic chemistry models is used to explore t
he effect of model selection on the results. Comparisons with the pred
ictions of Chester-Chisnell-Whitham (CCW) theory for the acceleration
of nonreactive shocks and detonations show quantitative agreement betw
een theory and simulation for symmetrically imploding waves. The influ
ence of structural supports in laboratory experiments on the symmetry
of imploding waves is simulated by placing an obstacle in the path of
the converging flow. Changes in the convergence time, reductions of th
e peak pressure at implosion, and deviations from symmetry during the
implosion induced by the obstacle are greater for detonations than for
the corresponding nonreactive shocks, in qualitative agreement with t
he linearized CCW theory for shocks and Chapman-Jouguet detonations. T
hese conclusions continue to hold when more sophisticated Zel'dovich-v
on Neumann-Doering or finite-rate chemistry models are assumed. For th
ese models, a substantial amount of new asymmetrical, dynamical struct
ure is evident in the reaction zone behind the leading shock. The resu
lts concur with and extend previous theoretical work suggesting that i
mploding detonation waves are relatively more unstable than nonreactiv
e shocks.