Dw. Onstad et F. Gould, MODELING THE DYNAMICS OF ADAPTATION TO TRANSGENIC MAIZE BY EUROPEAN CORN-BORER (LEPIDOPTERA, PYRALIDAE), Journal of economic entomology, 91(3), 1998, pp. 585-593
A deterministic population dynamics model was modified to include sing
le-locus, 2-allele genetics to simulate strategies for delaying resist
ance in the European corn borer, Ostrinia nubilalis (Hubner), populati
on to transgenic maize. We evaluated seed mixtures of transgenic and n
ontransgenic maize, B-row strips of nontransgenic plants, adjacent but
separate refuges of nontransgenic maize, and rotation of nontransgeni
c and transgenic maize. We studied how the choice of hybrid, planting
time, and weather may influence the selection of a tactic for delaying
resistance to transgenic maize. Our results indicate that separate re
fuges are superior to seed mixtures for delaying resistance. If a high
toxin dose cannot be achieved and a small fraction of homozygous susc
eptible and heterozygous European corn borer neonates survive on trans
genic maize, then resistance can develop in 10-33% of the time require
d under the assumption of a successful high dose that kills all hetero
zygous neonates. Planting e-row strips may be as good as separate refu
ges in delaying resistance, but their adoption carries greater risk be
cause of the uncertainty surrounding movement and survival of neonates
. The use of transgenic hybrids is the same whether or not they expres
s the toxin gene in silks and kernels of maize ears. Toxin titer decli
ne must be studied because our simulations indicate that development o
f resistance may be greatly hastened by this process.