The clinicopathological characteristics of breast cancer in 95 women b
etween the ages of 24 and 45 years with a family history of breast can
cer were compared with tumours from 329 women with sporadic disease ma
tched for age and year of diagnosis. There was a trend for the family
history patients to have slightly smaller tumours (mean size 2.49 cm)
than the controls (mean 3.04 cm) (Mann-Whitney test, P = 0.09). A sign
ificantly greater proportion of the familial cases had grade III infil
trating ductal carcinoma than did the controls (40% vs 27%; chi(1)(2)
= 5.64, P = 0.02). Despite this, there were more cases of operable nod
e-negative disease among the study group than among the controls (48%
vs 32%; chi(1)(2) = 8.2, P = 0.004). There was a highly significant su
rvival advantage for patients with a family history (chi(2) = 22.4, P
< 0.001). Five-and 10-year survival rates were 92% and 87% for those w
ith a family history compared with 70% and 54% for those in the contro
l group. This survival advantage was maintained when patients with ope
rable disease only were considered. In multivariate analysis, which in
cluded age, tumour size, stage, histological grade and family history,
family history was an independent predictor of favourable prognosis a
nd, in a Cox model, was associated with a relative risk of survival of
6.11 (95% CI 2.81-13.28). These results suggest that familial breast
cancer has a more favourable clinical course than the more common spor
adic forms of the disease.