Wh. James, WAS THE WIDESPREAD DECLINE IN SEX-RATIOS AT BIRTH CAUSED BY REPRODUCTIVE HAZARDS, Human reproduction (Oxford. Print), 13(4), 1998, pp. 1083-1084
There has been a decline in sex ratio at birth in recent decades in ma
ny countries. The question arises whether polluting environmental endo
crine disrupters may have been responsible. It is suggested here that
we are not (and will not soon become) in a position to know this becau
se: (i) we do not know what those sex ratios would have been doing in
the absence of such proposed polluters and (ii) there are plausible al
ternative explanations which themselves offer little prospect for test
ing. In short, the population sex ratio at birth seems not to be a use
ful monitor of reproductive hazard unless it were to change at a drama
tically greater rate than has ever been reported. This is not to deny
that offspring sex ratios of selected samples of workers have proved u
seful non-invasive indicators of reproductive hazard. However, the rec
ent tiny recorded secular declines in population sex ratios are distra
cting attention from the huge and unexplained changes in other monitor
s of reproductive hazard, e.g. the widespread decline in dizygotic twi
nning rates 1960-1980 and the recent probable decline in sperm counts.