B. Dubrulle et F. Graner, TITIUS-BODE LAWS IN THE SOLAR-SYSTEM .2. BUILD YOUR OWN LAW FROM DISKMODELS, Astronomy and astrophysics, 282(1), 1994, pp. 269-276
Simply respecting both scale and rotational invariance, it is easy to
construct an endless collection of theoretical models predicting a Tit
ius-Bode law, irrespective to their physical content. Due to the numer
ous ways to get the law and its intrinsic arbitrariness, it is not an
useful constraint on theories of solar system formation. To illustrate
the simple elegance of scale-invariant methods, we explicitly cook up
one of the simplest examples, an infinitely thin cold gaseous disk ro
tating around a central object. In that academic case, the Titius-Bode
law holds during the linear stage of the gravitational instability. T
he time scale of the instability is of the order of a self-gravitating
time scale, (G rho(d))(-1/2), where rho(d) is the disk density. This
model links the separation between different density maxima with the r
atio M(D)/M(C) of the masses of the disk and the central object; for i
nstance, M(D)/M(C) of the order of 0.18 roughly leads to the observed
separation between the planets. We discuss the boundary conditions and
the limit of the WKB approximation.