Jl. Nelson, THE MEANING OF THE ACT - REFLECTIONS ON THE EXPRESSIVE FORCE OF REPRODUCTIVE DECISION-MAKING AND POLICIES, Kennedy Institute of Ethics journal, 8(2), 1998, pp. 165-182
Prenatal and preconceptual testing and screening programs provide info
rmation on the basis of which people can choose to avoid the birth of
children likely to face disabilities. Some disabilities advocates have
objected to such programs and to the decisions made within them, on t
he grounds that measures taken to avoid the birth of children with dis
abilities have an ''expressive force'' that conveys messages disrespec
tful to people with disabilities. Assessing such a claim requires care
ful attention to general considerations relating meaning, intention, a
nd social practices; it has only begun to receive such attention. Buil
ding on work by Alien Buchanan, who has challenged this claim, I furth
er consider the disabilities advocates' objection, ultimately concludi
ng that it is misplaced; neither individual actions nor general practi
ces of this type necessarily express disrespectful messages.